I need a new anime?!?

Based on your list, you seem to like romance with an element of fantasy but not too overwhelming (me too!) Here are some like that which I watched and enjoyed: Hakushaku to Yousei (aka Earl and Fairy), Spice and Wolf, Full Moon wo Sagashite, Shugo Chara!, Ookami-san to Shichinin no Nakama-tachi. Some that I recommend that don't have a fantasy element but are good romances anyway: ITAZURA NA KISS (goes from high school all the way to college, very thorough and touching), KIMI NI TODOKE (a lovely and sweet high school romance), LOVELY COMPLEX (high school, this was so funny but sweet!), LAMUNE (a very gentle high school romance between childhood friends with a little drama), TORADORA (a great and cute romantic high school comedy!), PEACH GIRL (high school, lots of romance but tons of drama!) , and NANA (it has college age people but so dramatic and romantic and lots of good music, and you will love the friendship between the two Nanas. The most mature anime out of the ones I listed. This is one of my favorites!)